Skip to main contentSkip to footer
Meineke Car Care logo

August 12, 2024

Topping Off vs. Oil Change. Best Advice For a Smart Choice

Topping Off the Oil vs. an Oil Change Service: Pros and Cons

Picture this: You were heading back from the Old Beach Farmers Market this weekend, when you noticed your car running a bit rough. So, you pulled over and - being the responsible car owner that your are - checked your ride's fluids. And that when you noticed that your oil was a bit low.

So, what to do? When it comes to engine oil, car owners are often faced with a decision: should you just top off the oil when it's low, or should you opt for a full oil change service? Both options have their virtues. So in this blog, the experts at Meineke in Virginia Beach look at the pros and cons of topping off your oil or having an oil change service. Because understanding them can help you make the best choice for your vehicle's health.

Pros of Topping Off the Oil

  1. Convenience and Time-Saving: Topping off your oil is quick and easy. So, if you notice that your oil level is low, you can simply add more oil to bring it back to the recommended level. And this can be done in a matter of minutes without requiring a trip to Meineke on Diamond Springs Road.

  2. Cost-Effective in the Short Term: Adding a quart of oil is much cheaper than paying for a full oil change service. And this can be particularly appealing if you're on a tight budget or if your oil level has only dropped slightly between scheduled oil changes.

  3. Immediate Solution: If your oil light comes on or if you notice low oil levels during a routine check, topping off the oil can be a quick fix to prevent potential damage to your engine until you can schedule a full oil change.

Cons of Topping Off the Oil

  1. Doesn’t Address Oil Degradation: While topping off the oil brings the level back up, it doesn’t address the fact that the existing oil may be dirty or degraded. Because, over time, oil loses its effectiveness in lubricating and protecting your engine. And simply adding more oil won’t solve this issue.

  2. Potential for Overfilling: If you're not careful, topping off your oil can lead to overfilling. And this can cause excessive pressure in the engine, leading to oil leaks or even damage to engine components.

  3. False Sense of Security: Topping off the oil might make you feel like your engine is in good shape, but it can mask underlying issues. Whereas a regular oil change includes inspections that can catch these problems early.

Pros of an Oil Change Service

  1. Thorough Maintenance: A full oil change service involves draining the old, dirty oil and replacing it with fresh oil. And this ensures that your engine is properly lubricated and protected. In addition, this process also includes replacing the oil filter. And a fresh oil filter is critical to removing contaminants from the oil.

  2. Prevents Long-Term Damage: Regular oil changes help to prevent the buildup of sludge and debris in your engine, which can lead to serious issues over time. So, by keeping your engine clean and well-lubricated, you reduce the risk of costly repairs down the road.

  3. Opportunity for Inspection: During an oil change, mechanics typically perform a basic inspection of your vehicle. And this can include checking for leaks, assessing the condition of other fluids, and ensuring that your vehicle is in good overall health. Furthermore, catching potential problems early can save you money and hassle later on.

Cons of an Oil Change Service

  1. Requires a Little More Time: An oil change service takes more time than simply topping off the oil. So, you’ll need to schedule an appointment,

  2. Higher Cost: Of course, a full oil change service is more expensive than just adding a quart of oil. However, this cost is justified by the comprehensive care your vehicle receives during the service. And this will more than make up for the investment.

Meineke Can Help You Make the Right Choice for Your Vehicle, Your Lifestyle, and Your Wallet

Both topping off the oil and opting for an oil change service have their place in vehicle maintenance. And Meineke in Virginia Beach can help you determine which option is best for you. Topping off the oil can be a quick fix in a pinch, but it shouldn’t replace regular oil changes. Because, regular oil change services are key for keeping your engine clean, lubricated, and running smoothly. So, when in doubt, consult your locally-owned, ASE certified Meineke on Diamond Springs Road in Virginia Beach.

If the Meineke on Diamond Springs Road in Virginia Beach is not a convenient, check out these other locally-owned Meineke locations:

Locations
Services
Coupons
Rewards